Home » Guides » Operations » Purchasing » Evaluating Competing Vendors

Jennifer Nichols

Guide to Evaluating Competing Vendors

Narrow your options with an eye for price and service level

By Jennifer Nichols, Online Marketing Specialist

Even if you're a sole proprietor, you know that a successful business is more than its owner. Strong companies, no matter the size, depend on strong relationships — with customers, with partners and, of course, with vendors and suppliers — to stay afloat.

Building a team of reliable vendors isn't always easy, though. It requires patience, persistence and a keen knowledge of what works for your business and what doesn't. Key to success is starting with a long list of options, and ending with a short list of chosen vendors, a dream team of select suppliers. In narrowing down your list of potential vendors, keep the following top of mind:

  1. Your service requirements
  2. Your budget
  3. Your technical requirements

Action Steps
The best contacts and resources to help you get it done


Build your initial list of candidates

Compile a list of potential vendors using local suppliers, or broaden your horizons by including out-of-state and even foreign vendors.
I recommend: Locate a variety of small business vendors based upon your specific needs at Respond.com, where you can browse a vendor directory and read vendor referrals. BuyerZone also is a premium location for comparing vendors across hundreds of business purchasing categories.

Automate your evaluations

If you plan to evaluate several vendors, you may want to create a Request for Information (RFI), a Request for Quotation (RFQ), or a Request for Proposal (RFP) from your vendors in an effort to make the playing field as level as possible. An "RFx" is the general term to include all three types of documents.
I recommend: Make yours an Electronic Request for Proposal (eRFPs) by using a web-based solution from Sysoft to automatically consolidate and track responses as they come in from each vendor.

Use word of mouth

Recommendations from your peers are always your best evaluation tool. Ask around to find out who your friends and fellow business owners have worked with.
I recommend: If you want to consult a more "official" source, visit the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and find out what others have to say about the vendors on your list. If you're doing business online, the site provides a list of Internet-friendly companies that are safe to work with.

Bid for good deals

Online bidding isn't just for large corporations. Also called "reverse auctions," this is a tool to evaluate a large number of vendors, mainly on price, to save you lots of money.
I recommend: Hedgehog can manage the entire auction process for you and your suppliers, or you can purchase its software to do it yourself.

Assess technical capabilities

If you currently use a Customer Relationship Management (CRM) program in your organization, you'll want to make sure competing vendors are willing and/or able to use it.
I recommend: CLP Suites is an inexpensive solution that uses the Web for its CRM platform; there's a tiered pricing system based on the size of your business.

Negotiate and evaluate

Take notes at vendor meetings to help you remember what terms were discussed. Refer back to your notes during contract negotiations if necessary, and use them to barter with competing vendors, who may be able to offer the same suite of products or services at a better price.
I recommend: The Council for Entrepreneurial Development (CED) in North Carolina provides negotiation tactics for entrepreneurs just starting out, while MyWorkTools.com sells a vendor scorecard with which to evaluate and select winning vendors.

If necessary, customize

Don't stop looking until you find the vendor that will give you what you're looking for. If you choose a vendor, and find out later that they can't make good on their promises, there are many more fish in the virtual sea. Move on.
I recommend: At GlobalSpec.com, you can find an engineer to design, build and test any gadget you dream up.

Tips & Tactics
Helpful advice for making the most of this Guide

  • Notify existing suppliers of your search for new vendors in order to leverage better deals with them.
  • Ask potential vendors thorough questions in order to solicit honest, objective answers.
  • Find out when a vendor can and will ship your purchase, as shipping can be a huge differentiator when you need items quickly.

The official source of Evaluating Competing Vendors is
the Competitive Intelligence Consultants page at Business.com

Microsoft® System Center - Free Trial
Automate Deployment, Consolidate & Virtualize Servers, & More. Download Today!
Try It Out | Read White Paper | Learn More | Resources
Microsoft.com/SystemCenter
Competitive Intelligence - Hoover's®
Quickly compare companies to their competitors. Up-to-date financials, trends, competitor lists, & more. 32MM companies & 600 industries. Free Trial.
www.hoovers.com/intelligence
Competitive Insights
Gain insight from American Express to help you grow your market share.
americanexpress.com/bizinsights
Competitive Intelligence
Customized Competitive Intelligence. In over 50 Countries and more than 15 Languages.
All Industries | Read Testimonials | Contact Us | Request Proposal
www.infiniti-research.com

Recommended Solution Providers

Supplier Select: Vendor Evaluation
Offers online vendor application for RFPs and quotes.

Next Level Purchasing: Supplier Evaluation
Offers a class in supplier evaluation.

Cedar Crestone: Management Consulting
Offers management consulting, including suppler and vendor evaluation.

Dot Staff: Vendor Evaluation Software
Provides vendor evaluation software solutions.

Best Sites to Learn More

Entrepreneur.com: Find and Work with Suppliers
Information on creating criteria for evaluating vendors.

IT World: Vendor Evaluation Articles
Links to articles about evaluating vendors.

CIO Resources: Evaluating IT Vendors
Articles and links on evaluating and negotiating with IT vendors.

Network World: Writing an RFP
Information on writing a request for proposal (RFP), complete with a section on evaluating vendors.

ILSR: Ideal Procurement Process
Tips and information on creating a procurement process.



FEATURED LISTINGS

What WorksTM for Purchasing

Mark Ingebretsen

Avoiding Small Business Scams

With con artists using mail, phone and the Web, businesses have never been more vulnerable
From identity theft, to bogus emails (phishing), to elaborate cons, business owners today face scams from well-trained, tech-savvy criminals who often operate from countries beyond the reach of law enforcement. Besides costing your company money, time and lost productivity, scam artists can: Destroy your company's reputation with customers. Subject you to potential civil and legal penalties if you fail to adequately protect ... Read more

Free B2B search marketing whitepaper, B2B Search Marketing Strategy Guide: Advice From the Pros.
Download

To advertise on Business.com, click here