Is it safer to run my own business or work for a larger company?
I have been working on my own business, more as a hobby, on the side and am now working to make it a full-time business. I have been debating with my wife the security of having my own business as opposed to working for a larger company, which I have done most of my career. I am curious what others think about this topic.
Expert Answers
Sort by Date
Sort by Votes
Aug 26, 2016
I made the choice to have my own business, though I have also worked in regular positions at larger companies. I've decided that with layoffs so prevalent, there's always risk and less job security than in the past decades.
There is a risk in being on your own. Your name may not be well known in the marketplace, in which case you'll be developing a client base (which has already been done to a significant degree in larger companies). You possibly have some steady customers already, since you're doing business part time -- but now, you'll be doing the work but also doing your business development as a higher priority (unless/until you hire people/consultants) so you may not have much personal time anymore; and if you're in a professional services industry you may find your business has peaks and valleys. I think managing time and money etc. is more challenging and more important a skill when you're on your own, and you do not have the resources of a bigger company available as you do when you're an employee somewhere. You'll also need to pay for your own training and development to stay totally up to date in your field, as an expert your customers can trust. And, you may need to consider having a workplace away from home to improve your business location and better separate your family from your office and its visitors.
All of this will affect your wife, too. The rewards for each of us are probably different; for me, having my own business enables me to do the work I love, creatively and with high quality, without concern for internal company politics. I wish you all the very best.
Jun 7, 2016
What's your preference? Having your own business provides you the flexibility to make your own hours but you will have to work hard. Working for a large company provides you a steady paycheck but it's not secure. What happens if the company has a reorg? Can your business sustain your lifestyle? Is it something you enjoy? You need to sit down and really strategize on the better option. Only you can decide what to do - we can provide us based on what we know but in the end, it's up to you. Good luck.
Jun 7, 2016
I think this is almost like when deciding to have a baby. There will never be enough stability, enough money, have traveled enough, have done enough with your partner alone, big enough house, small enough mortgage, big enough car, etc. etc. But you know in your heart, that is what you want to do and you just need to take the plunge.
Starting your own business: you will never have enough contacts, a big enough network, enough savings, good enough idea, enough security, etc. One thing I have learned in the past 20 years is that sometimes you have to start several businesses to be successful, you will fail, you will feel happy, worried, sad, and then happy again. But you will never know if you can do it until you try it. Not everyone is cut for it, but how will you know? there is a big chance you will fail, so what? there is also a chance you succeed or learn learn a lot in the process.
My thought on working for a big firm: you have a feeling of security but do you really have it? you can be fired anytime and then what? look for another one, that takes time too, it is a project in itself. When you have your own business, you are forced to expand your network, know the latest trends, technology, etc. be in the know. If you lose a contract, you already have all that in place to look for another one, you have time to catch up, take some time off, etc. One advice I got a few years back was to always save 50% of what I make so that I have that money there for when I am looking for a new contract, so that I can take some time off, study some, etc. To see the downtime as a positive thing and not get desperate.
Also, my wife has a steady job, we get her pay check on a regular basis, benefits, that also helps to have piece of mind.
May 31, 2016
We could not have said it any better than Mike Sutton above, we would only add that your risk tolerance is a major factor.
Regardless of working for your own company or for a large company; it is always good to have at least 12 months of income stream(savings). This is beneficial should you not have the ability to produce income (either having left your employer or due to the growth stage of your business.) Or if you have a mature business but for some reason your business gets slow.
Having multiple income streams are also a VERY good option to have as well!
May 30, 2016
It's not an easy question to snswer. If you have a will, an opportunity... you have to run your own bussiness
May 19, 2016
I wouldn't say it's necessarily "safer." It's definitely different & to some extent you have a lot more control over your fate. But,how "safe" it is depends on your business, the market, how you're running your business and a little luck. I have been a one-person consulting business for 15 years and there have been ups and downs. Sometimes I have more work than I can handle & have to outsource & other times I've struggled to make ends meet. One thing I do recommend is that if possible, at least one of you keeps your "regular" job to cover benefits & maintain a steady income base for awhile, as you grow your business. Good luck!
May 19, 2016
This really is a personal decision. Owning your own business gives you great freedom, but you have to understand it is your business and not your personal bank account. To many people will live off their business which eat away at the business profit. In fact there are CPA which will talk you into do just that, live off the business. Here the problem, if you work from home and you write off part of your house, buy items under the business name and etc. If the business fails, your collectors or creditor have right to collect. That car under the business name, repo. If you live in a state like Texas where personal creditor can't foreclose on you home, business creditor can even if you own the home out right.
Flip, working for a business. You are just in the rat race and today there is no loyalty to the employee or business.
May 19, 2016
There's lot of writing on the web about the value of side projects. What I've read is that you know when to abandon your job and turn your side project into your job when you are spending more time/energy/thought on the side project.
Safer? that's a matter of personal preference. I personally believe that working for myself lets have me have more influence over my future. Control is illusory, influence is possible. When someone else is signing your paycheck, you will never be entirely safe. BUT you need to have the stomach for it. And since you mentioned your wife, she must Must MUST agree to this or it will never work.
May 19, 2016
A great question and some great answers here...
You have the 'luxury' of having worked your own business idea on the side for a while. That is a great way to get started. As a result, you should have a feel for whether there is a real demand for your product/service or not. Even if you have had success, make sure you determine the total size of the market and honestly consider your competition.
So, realistically ensure there is a real and big-enough demand for your product/service, ensure you have clear differentiation from your competition, and make sure you have enough cash to support the start-up.
Stating the obvious, you are better to say with your job than to start up a business that will fail. There is no certainty either way, but at a minimum, continue to see if you can build your own business on the side. If you answer the above questions positively, then take the leap. If you can't, yet, then stay with your job knowing that you continue to build a side business which you can fall back on if the worst happens from "the man".
May 18, 2016
I have learned one simple truth. There is no guarantees whether you work for a large company or yourself. Big companies have layoffs due financial difficulties and small business cannot workout as well. There is little security either way in my opinion. At least with your own company sky is the limit and you decide your fate.
May 18, 2016
Nothing hard about this, "safer" is a risk question. The rule of large numbers says statistically there is more job stability in corporate employement and more money.
Now you tell me if that's really the question. What do you want? I work as a financial advisor, risk has to do with sleeping at night and supporting those you have relationships with. If you want to find someone here who will support you in a debate with your wife, apologize to her now because I bet her intuition may be good.
Drive over to Greenwich and find some VC money people and load them up with your beer. If one of them wants more, you just found your business partner.
May 18, 2016
If you are that worried about safety you better not go into business for yourself. A secure career is what you make it to be. How badly do you want control over your own destiny? As a business owner you will learn to deal with difficult customers, employees, local and federal government, your industry and it's changes. Being the boss is not for the faint of heart. True entrepreneurs deal with want the day brings and love doing it. The challenge is part of what makes it worth doing. If you are not ready to put yourself on the line and test how resourceful you are. Take a job with some firm that will pay you what they think you are worth. If you want the big bucks, then go for it. Be smart build a plan and work your plan. You will have a much better chance to succeed if you have a plan.
John E. Stanojev, RFC
President
Capital Ins. & Inv. Planning, LLC
www.capitalinsureinvest.com
May 18, 2016
The answer, I suspect might lay in what you and your wife define as 'safe'? Often couples have different perspectives on this and it can ruin a perfectly good marriage if we get it wrong.
'Cashflow is always King' and whilst there may be other considerations to bear in mind such as quality of life, health, etc I suspect your wife might want you to consider that very carefully before making a move, particularly if you have never been in business before.
May 17, 2016
First, there is no such thing as "safe" or "secure". These concepts have not been realities for at least one generation.
Depends on whether you want to be master of your own destiny or a victim of someone else's decisions.
A generation or so ago, working for a big outfit - such as IBM, for example - was safe compared to setting up your own show. But hasn't IBM laid off tens of thousands of employees every year for several years. To cap it off, the company is now apparently going to only offer a severance package equivalent to one month of benefits compared to six months previously. So, unless you find something else fast, you had better have several months worth of living expenses stashed away.
Jobs have been cut by big companies across just about every industry.
I recommend that people working for companies squirrel away at least three months of basic living expenses and take out income protection insurance which cuts in after a month or two and pays at least 60% of your provable income every month for a year. (If you try hard enough, you can trim 40% of your living expenses. And don't forget that having a job costs money - transport, parking, clothes, lunches, coffees and so forth.)
You should do the same if you have your own business.
May 11, 2016
It really depends upon the business you are doing.Every business has pro & cons.So down and on the piece of paper write down merits and demerits and by the end you feel you can do smoothly do that business with conviction.
May 11, 2016
I can't help but recall an article by Gary Vaynerchuk in Medium - https://medium.com/@garyvee/my-advice-for-first-time-entrepreneurs-efb45e69967d#.5hpaailu6
He says - by starting a business, you (first-time entrepreneurs) have made a decision that does not allow you any time, in your first year, to do anything but build your business. (I believe this 'first year' may easily roll on to become first couple of years or even more!)
He also says later - We are absolutely living through the greatest generation of fake entrepreneurship that we’ve seen in a long time.
There is also another widely read article in Medium by Jeff Goins - Why Quitting Your Job to Chase Your Dream Is a Terrible Idea, https://medium.com/life-learning/why-quitting-your-job-to-chase-your-dream-is-a-terrible-idea-a3269e281eda#.x0vlr0y91.
I mention them first because - and as I know myself - entrepreneurship is a tough game. It's not only about your products and competition, but also about finances and your uncanny ability to foresee the future and adapt to the changes.
In my opinion, you can continue with your job while your wife (at the risk of knowing nothing about her) can dip her feet in business. Later, you'll yourself realize that the time has come to go the whole hog.
All the best.
May 11, 2016
Generally speaking, most would agree it's safer to work for "the man", but you can still get downsized, and there's little fulfillment in building someone else's wealth or dream. Perhaps a better question to ask is whether it is necessary to choose between one and the other, the answer to which is "no".
Once you've discovered this, the next question to ask is "am I willing to do what it takes to hold down a fulltime job while getting my business into positive cash flow?"
Another question to ask if you're wavering is "am I willing to play it safe all my life and bury my dreams?"
If you answered "no", I'd be happy to chat with you to see how best to get your business cash flow positive (after covering your expenses) as quickly as possible and with the least stress possible. There is a way. You just don't have all the information about that yet.
May 11, 2016
There's a lot of espionage going on in the business world. A lot of back-stabbing and cheating. I think the first thing you have to get settled is how you would face the rigors of this bear-bull market and the prevalence of intervention by shadowy figures, the potential for riots, shortages of important items, and the rest which goes with a failing or soon to fail economy.
May 11, 2016
It takes a certain type of individual to run their own business and you will definitely need the support of your wife. However, I found that being the 'Queen" bee rather than a 'worker' has many benefits and is much more fulfilling, long-term, providing you work hard and create a successful business.
May 11, 2016
I get a paycheck once a month for the company I work for. I happen to be the owner of the company I work for and wouldn't have it any other way. You don't say what you do. I have a bookkeeping and accounting systems consulting firm. So lets assume your business will be a business w/multiple clients vs. your job w/1 employer. Your livelihood is based on a few things a) are you good at what you do and b) do your clients/employer need you to do it. If one of your clients no longer need your service, it might sting for awhile, but you will go find another client to replace that income and then all will be right with the world again. However if your employer no longer needs you then you will be in a world of hurt. A lot of individuals state there is more stability with a job. And while that may be true for some, for me it has never been that way as my stability was based one one. While in my business my stability is based on many. Also having my own business gives me the ability to fire clients I do not wish to work for should they not meet my standards. Perhaps they don't treat my staff well, or they don't pay their bills, or they aren't ethical. With a job, you are kind of caught between a rock and a hard place. Now having said all that, as an owner of a company and especially a start up it will be all work and no play and Jeff will be come a very dull boy. But all that work and attention all being well will hopefully pay off in the end. I have been at it since 1993, don't regret it for a moment, I still work 7 day weeks more often than not, however while I may work hard, I play hard too.
Just came across this quote by Warren Buffet - "Never test the depth of river with both feet."
I guess it makes sense to what I wrote above.