Business.com aims to help business owners make informed decisions to support and grow their companies. We research and recommend products and services suitable for various business types, investing thousands of hours each year in this process.
As a business, we need to generate revenue to sustain our content. We have financial relationships with some companies we cover, earning commissions when readers purchase from our partners or share information about their needs. These relationships do not dictate our advice and recommendations. Our editorial team independently evaluates and recommends products and services based on their research and expertise. Learn more about our process and partners here.
Merit increases can reward and motivate employees, but they must be planned and implemented carefully.
A merit pay increase can motivate top-performing employees and improve worker retention. However, implementing a merit increase successfully requires planning and clear guidelines. Before moving forward, it’s essential to understand exactly how merit pay works and how to develop a system for pay increases over time.
Merit pay is performance-based compensation given to employees who excel at their jobs. For example, employees who meet specific business goals within a set timeframe may be rewarded with merit pay.
Merit pay acts as a financial incentive for an employee’s hard work and usually takes the form of a raise. In some companies, additional recognition may come as an employee bonus or promotion. However, you should establish explicit requirements regarding merit pay increases or employees who don’t receive one may create a toxic work environment.
“A focus on merit pay is a great way to motivate your employees, especially if you have a lot of new hires looking to establish themselves and clear, objective performance metrics you can use to track performance,” explained Hayden Cohen, CEO of Hire with Near. “Good compensation packages will include some merit-based elements along with raises for seniority and cost of living.”
Merit pay can help you recruit new employees, hire top talent, improve employee retention and boost productivity.
Merit pay is awarded to employees for reaching company goals or exceeding expectations. In contrast, pay raises are often modest — usually 1 percent to 5 percent — and typically are given to all employees based on tenure or to keep up with cost-of-living increases.
“A merit increase is a pay raise that rewards employees for their performance while a pay raise is a general increase in salary,” explained Jess Smith, chief people officer at Hays America. “[A merit increase] is designed to reward employees on performance to help motivate colleagues to do their best work and help accomplish the organization’s goals.”
Daniel Space, a senior human resources (HR) director and HR content creator, clarified that all merit increases are pay raises — but not all pay raises are merit-based.
“We usually see three primary types of pay increases,” Space explained. “Merit is the most common, [followed by] market adjustments, where someone is performing the same role but the market now pays that role at a much higher rate and, finally there are promotions in which someone’s responsibility has increased and so their pay is raised to compensate for their additional responsibilities.”
Dovilė Gelčinskaitė, senior talent manager at Omnisend, sees merit-based pay as more effective than standard raises.
“Often, salaries get raised simply to keep up with inflation and industry trends, not necessarily to reward great performance,” Gelčinskaitė noted. “Merit increases, on the other hand, inherently tie compensation to an employee’s actual contributions. Here, there’s greater capacity for increased motivation and aligning individual performance with company goals.”
The best online payroll services support merit pay and pay raises and make it easy to change pay rates. Read our Paychex review and our review of Gusto to learn about two top-tier flexible solutions.
A standard merit increase is what a company offers for its performance-based monetary incentives. According to Mercer’s United States Compensation Planning Survey, the average 2024 merit increase was 3.3 percent among reporting companies. That’s down from 4.4 percent in 2023.
However, Space noted that in many corporations, the actual average is closer to 2.8 percent — often not enough to keep up with inflation. “It doesn’t keep up with the rising cost of living,” Space explained, “so it often leaves workers feeling they’re still behind, even after a raise.”
Keep the following in mind:
A merit pay program can be one part of a strategy to overcome hiring challenges in a tight labor market.

Merit pay can bring numerous benefits to businesses, including the following:
Promoting from within can be a powerful motivator, but keep in mind that someone who excels in their role may not automatically succeed in a leadership position.
Consider the following best practices when developing merit increase standards to help prevent employees from becoming disgruntled or confused:
Improve your merit pay system by conducting regular stay interviews to assess your employees’ well-being and garner feedback. If employees leave, conduct exit interviews to learn what they liked — and didn’t like — about your compensation structure and work environment.

As a business owner or manager, you want to reward your top performers — but you also have to keep an eye on the budget. Striking the right balance isn’t always easy. Here are some practical tips to help you navigate merit pay negotiations with fairness and confidence:
Taking this overall approach can turn stressful negotiations into valuable two-way conversations that motivate staff and build longer-term loyalty to your business.
Businesses must first consider their merit pay budget when planning merit increases. Determining whether your company pays below market, at market or above market can help you finalize the budget and decide how to evaluate employee performance.
Space recommends calculating the merit budget as a percentage of total salaries — for example, multiplying all salaries by 3 percent to determine the overall merit pay pool.
There are two common methods for calculating individual merit increases: Broadbanding and compa-ratio.
Broadbanding
Broadbanding doesn’t rely on a midpoint salary, giving businesses flexibility to use a wider-than-standard salary range for a role. After setting your merit pay budget, review last year’s evaluations to find the average employee rating. Once you’ve calculated the average, set a baseline percentage increase. Then, work above and below that average to create tiered merit pay increases.
Example rating system:
Compa-ratio
This approach makes the pay of your most productive employees more competitive than that of their co-workers. Once an employee reaches a high payroll threshold, their raises are lower. The compa-ratio method helps control payroll costs while still rewarding strong performance.
For example, let’s say a company sets a salary range for a credit controller between $40,000 and $60,000. The midpoint of that range is $50,000. To find an employee’s compa-ratio, divide their current salary by the midpoint.
If the lower-paid employee performs exceptionally well, they might receive a 10 percent merit increase, bringing their salary to $46,200. Since the other employee is already near the top of the range, they might receive only a 2 percent raise, increasing their salary to $59,160.
This approach allows you to reward performance while keeping salaries aligned with your compensation structure.
While merit pay can raise the bar on company standards, improve employee engagement and increase profits, there are a few disadvantages:
Yes, it’s possible to negotiate a merit pay increase. However, managers may not have access to additional funds. Merit pay programs usually have an overall budget for a set period. That budget is divided between managers. Managers must be fair to their employees and divide it based on their evaluations of employees’ work performance.
However, don’t hesitate to ask if additional merit pay funds are available. Armed with your accomplishments, awards and market value salary, have an upfront conversation with your manager about your financial expectations. Your manager should be able to provide a timeline for additional raises and provide you with the specifics on what you must do to receive the pay you deserve. If your manager asks you to complete specific skills or goals by a set date, stick to the deadline. Use this to your advantage when the next raise opportunity arises.
No. While a bonus can be based on merit (for example, when an employee achieves certain performance milestones), it is a one-time payment. A merit pay increase continues each pay period. It’s crucial to watch your overall merit budget because merit increases can max out a top performer’s salary. Changing incentives to one-time bonuses can still reward top-performing employees without bumping their salaries to management levels.
Management must set performance criteria to qualify an employee for merit pay. Managers must have regular performance appraisal discussions with employees to review each person’s performance and identify problems and areas of excellence. During performance appraisals, employee performance should be compared to preset benchmarks established and communicated beforehand. Employees who fall short should be told how to improve to get a merit pay increase in the next appraisal cycle.
A merit pay increase should go into effect within a month of the performance appraisal in which the employee qualified. This timeframe is soon enough to serve as a motivating reward but gives enough time for your payroll personnel to make the needed changes.
Julie Thompson contributed to this article.